A battery of journalism professionals and academics representing a host of major organizations in late 2012 and early 2013 conducted research aimed at producing practical recommendations for combating and dealing with plagiarism and fabrication. Their conclusions were presented at the National Summit on Plagiarism and Fabrication, part of the 2013 ACES conference in St. Louis.
The group was recruited by Teresa Schmedding, the ACES president, and was headed by William G. Connolly, a retired senior editor of the New York Times. It was divided into three committees, each studying one aspect of the problem – how to define it, how to prevent it, and how to deal with it when necessary.
Among the organizations represented in the effort are the Associated Press Media Editors, the Society of Professional Journalists, the Online News Association, the American Society of News Editors, the Canadian Association of Journalists, the Radio-Television Digital News Association, the Local Independent Online News Publishers and the College Media Advisers.
Download the e-book the group created here.
Download the PowerPoint presentation on the group’s work here.
See our articles from the National Summit on Plagiarism and Fabrication here.
HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE SUMMIT BLOG
After the summit: The continuing efforts to raise awareness of plagiarism
What Mizzou does: The Columbia Missourian’s policy on plagiarism
The summit in tweets: Feel like you were there in this Storify
Won’t come to the summit? A call to the serial plagiarist who got $20,000 to speak about what he did
Catch it: Bill Connolly’s tips for spotting fabrication
The blog that started it all: Craig Silverman’s “Summer of Sin” post that got the summit going
Princeton University’s examples of plagiarism, from the Academic Integrity section of its website
PLAGIARISM IN THE NEWS
The Guardian: Damien Hirst accused of plagiarism again with GQ cover of Rihanna as Medusa. Blog post.
Christian radio host Janet Mefferd vs. Seattle pastor Mark Driscoll: Mefferd accused Driscoll on the air Nov. 21 of plagiarism in his new book, examples were cited on her show’s website and elsewhere, then Mefferd apologized for the allegations Dec. 4 and removed them all from the show website.
• Religion News Service: Mefferd in heated interview accuses Driscoll of 14 pages of plagiarism in his book. Column on the radio interview.
• RNS’s Jonathan Merritt blog: A summary of the allegations and controversy, with examples illustrated, and updated with news of Mefferd’s retraction.
• Orlando Sentinel’s The Religion World blog: Another summary of the controversy.
• Right Wing Watch: Summary of the controversy with Mefferd’s apology and other commentary noted, such as, “Is journalism no longer considered a legitimate Christian calling?”
• Christianity Today: Another summary of the controversy with notes of past plagiarism accusations and consequences in the Christian community.
The Malaysian Insider: “Plagiarism is a sin” — commentary on a hot Malaysian case, with excerpts of Harvard University’s policy.
Bloomberg: Georgetown law professor accused of plagiarizing Wikipedia. Full story.
The Guardian: “Rand Paul and Lee Terry plagiarized. But the real concern is how the repetition of talking points manipulates public opinion” (with mention of the Iranian president’s plagiarism and other cases among politicians). Full column.
CBS News, “Plagiarism: Stopping Word Thieves”: A writer steals the bulk of his novel’s words from various sources, an interview with Jayson Blair, catching plagiarism in students’ papers, and more. Story and video.
St. Louis Public Radio: Journalism and the Public Trust: The Recurring Role of Jayson Blair. “One of the things that I really wanted to do in the film is illuminate the fact that this is not a standard case of plagiarism and fabrication,” documentary filmmaker says. Full story and video.
University Daily Kansan apologizes for fabrication in opinion column. Full story.
Chronicle of Higher Education: ”Overworked” Kean U. administrator neglects attribution in portion of report, resigns. Full story.
The Hill: Why Rand Paul’s Plagiarism Matters — an opinion.
Clevescene.com: Ex-Kent St. Ph.D. candidate’s lawsuit: No such thing as plagiarism in a first draft. Full story.
RT: Washington Times ends Rand Paul’s column over plagiarism allegations. Full story.
NPR: Was Rand Paul’s plagiarism dishonest or a breach of good form? Full story.
Stephen Colbert mocks Rand Paul lifting “Gattaca” movie lines from Wikipedia. Story and clip.
New York Times: Plagiarism lines blur for students in the digital age. Full story.
More links, particularly from 2012, a horrible year for plagiarism, here.